OnThisDayin1642: The stand-off at the Battle of Turnham Green

Standard

Turnham Green is a public park, around seven miles from the centre of London. With its George Gilbert Scott-designed church, war memorial, and old Town Hall, it’s typical of the capital’s civic green spaces.

1188527_9556ff4a.jpg

But 375 years ago today, it played host to a stand-off that helped change the course of British history.

After the indecisive battle of Edgehill, King Charles found he had an open road to London after a strategic mistake by the Earl of Essex, leader of the Parliamentarian army. Prince Rupert advised Charles to authorise an immediate cavalry strike against London before Essex’s army could return.

However, the King – hoping for Parliament to negotiate and offer terms – decided to make a more cautious advance with his whole army, which allowed Essex time to march back to London unopposed – he was greeted with a morale-boosting hero’s welcome for Essex upon his arrival on 7 November.

During Essex’s absence, Parliament had commissioned the Earl of Warwick to raise a further seven regiments for the city’s defence and the 6,000 men of the London Trained Bands were mobilised. Sir James Ramsay was sent with 3,000 troops from Essex’s main army to defend Kingston, the first crossing of the River Thames above London Bridge, and detachments were posted at Acton and Brentford to guard the western approaches to the City.

The King advanced on the capital via Banbury, Oxford, Reading and Windsor – not only had Parliament rejected Charles’ suggestion that the castle at Windsor be turned over to him as a venue for peace talks, but Rupert had then failed to take it.

On 12 November, the 13,000-strong Royalist army mustered on Hounslow Heath, 12 miles from London. Although he had agreed to meet a delegation of Parliamentarian commissioners at Colnbrook in Buckinghamshire, the King wanted to strengthen his position by intimidating his opponents and approved Prince Rupert’s proposal to attack an Parliamentarian outpost. Three Royalist regiments were resupplied with ball, powder and match and ordered to attack Brentford. Two regiments of foote under Denzil Holles and Lord Brooke held fortified positions in the town, which was a strategic river crossing. Rupert’s cavalry and dragoons advanced to the outskirts of the village under a thick early morning mist. His initial attack was repulsed by Parliamentarians around the house of Sir Richard Wynne, but Rupert ordered in a regiment of Welshmen to press the attack. They successfully captured the outpost and carried their attack into Brentford, driving Holles’ troops over a bridge into the defences manned by men commanded by Lord Brooke. These in turn were driven out of the town into open fields. The fighting continued into late afternoon until the survivors were able to disengage under the protection of John Hampden’s infantry, which arrived from Uxbridge to cover the withdrawal. Nevertheless, a large number of Holles’s men drowned while trying to escape by swimming across the Thames.

Having captured 15 guns, 11 colours and about 300 prisoners, the victorious Royalists looted Brentford. One of the prisoners was a Captain John Lilburne, the future Leveller leader. He had tried to escape by jumping in the Thames but was taken as a prisoner to Oxford (as the first prominent Roundhead captured in the war, the Royalists wanted to try Lilburne for high treason. But when Parliament threatened to execute Royalist prisoners in reprisal, Lilburne was exchanged for a Royalist officer. He later joined the Eastern Association under the Earl of Manchester)

Parliamentary propaganda played up the ferocity of Rupert’s attack and stressed the King’s duplicity in sanctioning the raid while peace negotiations were in progress. With enthusiastic support from the citizenry, the Earl of Essex brought together all available Parliamentarian forces to block any further Royalist advance. With his army reinforced by the Trained Bands and freshly recruited regiments under the Earl of Warwick, Essex fielded a force of more than 24,000 men to face the King.

The two armies drew up on 13 November to face one another in an open area formed by Turnham Green, Acton Green and Chiswick Common on the western outskirts of London.

TGMap1.jpg

Essex sent six regiments under the command of John Hampden to outflank the Royalists by occupying high ground to the north of the Royalist position, but then recalled them. He also withdrew the 3,000 men under Sir James Ramsay at Kingston and sent them to a new position on the Surrey side of London Bridge. While the reasoning behind Essex’s manoeuvres is obscure, the Royalists were in no position to exploit them, being too heavily outnumbered to risk a general assault.

The two armies faced one another all day with a few casualties resulting from exchanges of artillery fire and some skirmishing. As darkness began to fall, Lord Forth withdrew the Royalist army through Brentford to Hounslow Heath, covered by a rearguard commanded by Prince Rupert and Sir Jacob Astley.

Having prevented the Royalists from advancing on London, Essex made no move to pursue them as they withdrew westwards to Reading and then to Oxford, which became the King’s headquarters and Royalist capital for the duration of the war.

Both sides sent their main armies into winter quarters but London would never again be so closely threatened by the King’s forces. While Parliament never let up its nervous defence of the capitol, the stand-off at Turnham Green marks a turning point in the first English Civil War. Had Charles gotten to London first or persisted in his attack, the war could have been over in 1642. His reluctance to attack helped ensure there would be no swift end to the war.

Advertisements

What’s the future for the 17th Century on screen?

Standard

The English Civil War was one of the most turbulent periods of British history.

Between 1642 and 1651, the population of the British Isles would suffer a proportionally greater loss of life than it did during the First World War and the nine years of war would result in the deaths of over a quarter of a million. The destruction and devastating loss of life would eventually lead to the entrenching of Parliament as the primary source of government, the radically reduced power of the monarchy, and the formation of the first permanent and professional army in England.

But for all the monuments and plaques across the country, the film and television industry has largely overlooked the period. There have been a few exceptions — perhaps most notably the Richard Harris film, Cromwell — but why, compared to other periods of British history, has the English Civil War not generated the same level of interest, and what does the future hold for the 17th Century on screen? In the second part of his look at portrayals of the period on screen (part one is here), Earl of Manchester’s member David Rowlinson takes a look…

Money, Money, Money

Every film and television series, regardless of its budget, needs investment. The British film industry has always struggled when it comes to raising funds, and historical dramas are notoriously expensive, so it’s no surprise that the English Civil War, and perhaps the genre of the historical drama as a whole, has been somewhat overlooked by the film and TV industry. While there’s always the chance of a good performance at the box office or high ratings, studios are only likely to give the green light if they think a production is going to appeal to a wide audience, which brings us to…

Global Appeal

Before a production can hope for any investment, it needs to know that if it were to be made, there would be enough people wanting to see it to justify the studio putting their time and money into it. Other historical films and series that have proved successful, particularly those set in ancient Rome or the Tudor dynasty, have done well because the periods of history they portray are well known to an international audience. The English Civil War on the other hand, has not had the focus its importance deserves, to the point where there are now many misconceptions that simplify the war. There are not many examples of the English Civil War in film or TV, and those that exist are littered with damaging inaccuracies.

Films such as the 2003, To Kill A King, which flopped with both audiences and critics alike, discourage other filmmakers from examining the period and attempting to rectify the inaccuracies that have gone before. Until productions begin to portray the English Civil War accurately, its importance in British, and global, history will not be recognised to the extent it should. However, this may not be too far from happening…

A Renaissance?

While it may be a while before the English Civil War appears again on screen, the 17th Century as a whole is beginning to show signs of a resurgence in film and TV. Since 2008 there have been several notable productions, each with their own take on the 17th century.  The 2008 mini-series, The Devil’s Whore, was successful enough to warrant a sequel, The New World, and indeed the European settling of the Americas and the establishment of the colonies looks to be a setting new productions are eager to explore.

Films like the chilling horror, The Witch, and the English Civil War film, A Field In England, suggest that the 17th Century can be a setting for all kinds of genres and not just the traditional historical drama, and studios are beginning to show signs of faith in the era once again.

Sky 1’s Jamestown, which tells the story of women’s arrival at the colony of the same name, was commissioned for a second series before the first episode had even been broadcast, so for the decades of uncertainty surrounding the 17th Century on screen, its future is now beginning to look far more promising.

From swashbucklers and witchfinders to radicals and whores – the best of the 17th Century on the screen

Standard

From continental wars and revolutions to major advances in science and political ideas, the upheaval and conflict of the 17th Century produced many stories that filmmakers have attempted to retell on the big and small screen.

While ancient Rome and Edwardian country manors have always been more popular settings with audiences, the era of Cavaliers and Roundheads has not been without its own collection of films and television serials.

In the first of a two-part feature about the 17th Century on the screen, our member David Rowlinson takes a look at ten of the very best…

1) The Moonraker (1958)

Very much a part of the height of the swashbuckler era of filmmaking, The Moonraker tells the story of a mysterious Royalist hero on a mission to smuggle Prince Charles out of England after his defeat at the Battle of Worcester before Oliver Cromwell (played by Dad’s Army’s John Le Mesurier) can capture him.

GeorgeBakerTheMoonraker.jpg

2) Witchfinder General (1968)

Heavily censored in the UK on its initial release, Witchfinder General is a fictionalised account of the infamous witch hunter, Matthew Hopkins as he sweeps a reign of terror across East Anglia. Vincent Price would go on to rate his performance as Hopkins as his best, and the film is now regarded as one of the best horrors in the history of cinema.

static1.squarespace.png

3) Cromwell (1970)

Richard Harris plays the eponymous figure in one of the most famous and simplistic depictions of the English Civil War. The film is noted for its almost endless amount of historical inaccuracies – not only producing a near-libellous depiction of the Earl of Manchester but also having him, a lord, sitting in the House of Commons – but it has developed a cult following thanks to its spectacular battle sequences and stirring performances, particularly from Richard Harris and also Alec Guinness as King Charles I.

maxresdefault.jpg

4) Winstanley (1975)

Winstanley tells the story of social and religious reformer Gerard Winstanley who, along with a small band of followers known as the Diggers or True Levellers, occupied privatised lands and attempted to establish self-sufficient farming communities. The film went to great lengths to maintain a high level of historical accuracy, even going as far as to use genuine armour borrowed from the Tower of London, and Miles Halliwell as Winstanley reading the words of actual pamphlets of the time.

image-w1280.jpg

5) By the Sword Divided (1983-85)

This series ran on the BBC for two years and followed the struggles of two noble families, the Laceys and the Fletchers, as they found themselves on opposing sides during the English Civil War. The show was not without its critics, earning the phrase “by the sword defeated” by one reviewer, but it ran long enough to cover the history from the outbreak of the civil war to the restoration of the monarchy in 1660.

432277-15954-clp-950.jpg

6) The Three Musketeers (1993)

Not an accurate in its portrayal of 17th Century France by any means, but the 1993 adaptation of Alexandre Dumas’s novel did bring an infectious excitement to it that is hard to not enjoy. Featuring a cast including the scene-stealing Tim Curry as Cardinal Richelieu, The Three Musketeers simplifies its source material into an enjoyable action comedy – provided you can look past French musketeers speaking with American accents.

1993.jpg

7) Alatriste (2006)

Viggo Mortensen stars as Captain Alatriste, a soldier in the Spanish army during the Thirty Years War. The film, the second most expensive in Spanish film history, culminates in the battle of Rocroi with one of the best depictions of 17th Century warfare ever made for film or television.

539248-20037-clp-950.jpg

8) The Devil’s Whore (2008)

A four-part series set between 1642-1660 that follows the events of the English Civil War and years of the republic through the eyes of fictional heroine Angelica Fanshawe. Among the cast were well-known stars such as John Simm, Michael Fassbender and Peter Capaldi. A sequel, New Worlds, followed in 2014.

DevilsWhore6.png

9) A Field in England (2013)

Set in the aftermath of a civil war battle, A Field In England tells of a group of deserters who descend into madness when they eat from a field of hallucinogenic mushrooms. Unique and bold, director Ben Wheatley offers a new take on the historical drama genre.

2078394_orig.jpg

10) The Witch (2015)

The debut feature from writer-director Robert Eggers, The Witch tells the story of a Puritan family in colonial America who are tormented by an unknown evil lurking in the woods surrounding their home. The film received wide critical acclaim for its suspenseful atmosphere and accurate depiction of a 17th Century God-fearing populace.

the-witch-2015-4.jpg

375 years later, the English Civil War returns to Manchester

Standard
Nantwich 02 - Photo by Ammgramm on Flickr.jpgAlmost 375 years to the day since Manchester witnessed the first casualty of the English Civil War, the conflict is to be brought to life in Chadderton.
Foxdenton Park in Chadderton will go back in time to the 17th Century this weekend as The Earl of Manchester’s Regiment of Foote, part of the Sealed Knot reenactment society, reveals what life was like during the English Civil Wars of the 1640s in an event that is ideal for the whole family.
From 10am on Saturday and Sunday, visitors will be able to visit an authentic encampment in the park and meet the army on campaign, before Roundhead and Cavalier take part in two deadly skirmishes! 
With muskets, drums, and pike, costumed reenactors will recreate one of the many battles between the two competing sides. Who will be victorious in this battle for control of the nation – the King? Or Parliament?
At 10.30am, the armies will march from Kingfisher School on Foxdenton Lane before taking part in skirmishes at 11.45am and 2pm in Foxdenton Park. As well as the battles, there will be fascinating displays explaining 17th Century life and what it was like to take up arms in this so-called ‘war without an enemy’.
Manchester has the dubious distinction of being the site of the first casualty of the English Civil War: on 15th July 1642, weaver Richard Perceval died during a street fight in Manchester when Royalists tried to force the Parliamentarian town to hand over its gunpowder stores.
Perceval, from Levenshulme, was allegedly killed by Thomas Tyldesley of Astley – the first death in a conflict that would claim a greater proportion of lives than World War One.
The event will take place next to Foxdenton Hall, which reuses features and stonework from an earlier building of 1620, which was built for lord of the manor William Radclyffe. Radclyffe died along with his oldest son, Robert, at the Battle of Edgehill in 1642, the first pitched battle of the English Civil War.
Musket block (c) David Gee.jpg
About the Earl of Manchester’s Regiment of Foote:
Part of the Sealed Knot, the world’s oldest and Europe’s largest re-enactment society, the members of Earl of Manchester’s Regiment of Foote re-enacts a regiment from the English Civil Wars period from 1642-1660. They portray the lifeguard of Edward Montagu, the second Earl of Manchester, who was one of the leading generals in the First English Civil War of 1642-5. For more information, go to www.earlofmanchesters.co.uk
About The Sealed Knot:
Europe’s oldest and largest re-enactment society, The Sealed Knot was formed in Oxford in 1968 and has thousands of members across the UK, Europe, and the world. It stages dozens of events every year from commemorative marches and village fetes to massed battles. A registered educational charity, the Society aims not to glorify war but to honour those that died in the many battles of the English Civil War, and to educate the public about those wars, and also about the lives and times of people in that period.
The name of the Society derives from a group, which, during the Protectorate, plotted for the restoration of the monarchy; here the similarity ends though as the present society is a non-political charity that has both Parliamentarian and Royalist armies.
About the English Civil War:
The English Civil War was actually a series of armed conflicts between 1642 and 1652, culminating with the Restoration of King Charles II in 1660. Far more complex than simply ‘Roundheads versus Cavaliers’, the English Civil Wars was a tumultuous period when our modern nation state was first formed. Arguments between King Charles I and his Parliament over taxation, religion and control of the country boiled over into open conflict in 1642, with the country dividing into those who supported the King and those who supported Parliament. After the second Civil War, Oliver Cromwell rose to prominence and following Charles II’s failed invasion of England, Cromwell became head of the English Commonwealth and then king in all but name as Lord Protector. He died in 1658, but his son and successor Richard Cromwell quickly abdicated. Charles II returned and was restored as King of England in 1660.

This weekend: the Roundheads march into Wiltshire!

Standard

6723477_origChoose your side this Spring Bank Holiday weekend as we celebrate the 375th anniversary of the start of the English Civil War!

Amidst the glorious setting of Charlton Park, the Sealed Knot will bring this pivotal moment to life with a living history encampment across the weekend, plus dramatic cameos commemorating the history of the Howard family.

Set piece battles will take place on the Sunday and Monday showcasing the talents of musket, pike, cavalry and artillery!

Buy tickets here >>

Built by Lord Thomas Howard, 1st Earl of Suffolk, for his wife Catherine, Charlton Park House was ready for occupation by 1607. After Catherine’s death it was inherited by her second son, Thomas, who in 1626 was created the first Earl of Berkshire.

Malmesbury was held by the Royalists during the First Civil War but DAlghfNW0AAErMp.jpgsurrendered to Parliamentarian Colonel Massie in 1644, a Presbyterian officer who fought tirelessly against Royalists in the region. Massie eventually became commander of the Western Association army and, after the formation of the New Model Army, was given his own independent command. But after Charles I’s execution he switched sides to the Royalists, participating in the failed Scottish invasion of England in 1651 and fleeing with Charles II after the Battle of Worcester. He was captured but  escaped from the Tower of London by climbing out of a chimney. He later returned to try and spark a Royalist uprising but was again captured, again escaping and fleeing to the Continent. He returned to England in January 1660 and caused a riot in Gloucester when he stood for election to the Convention Parliament. But, after being duly elected, he supported the Restoration and was rewarded by Charles II for his services with a knighthood and a grant of money and lands in Ireland, where he died in 1674.

This event is being organised and run by Hopton’s Tercio of the Royalist army of the Sealed Knot Society.17504395_1656918467727426_53025364880548108_o.jpg

Find out where we’re battling this summer!

Standard

Fancy stepping back in time to one of the most tumultuous periods in British history?

Do you want to hear drums call ranks of musketeers and pikemen to order, cannons roaring besides them as preachers and officers exhort them into battle? Do you want to see how life was lived by ordinary people during the 17th Century?

We have a full schedule of events this summer where we’ll be heading back to the English Civil Wars and bringing this important period of history to life across the UK!

Here’s a list of where the Earl of Manchester’s Regiment of Foote will be appearing this year, check out the further details below or click on our interactive map!

  • Charlton Park, Wiltshire: Sat 27 May 2017 – Mon 29 May 2017
  • Newark, Nottinghamshire: Sat 22 Jul 2017 – Sun 23 Jul 2017
  • Tattershall Castle, Lincolnshire: Sat 05 Aug 2017 – Sun 06 Aug 2017
  • Scampston Hall, North Yorkshire: 25 August – 28 August
  • Lancaster Castle, Lancashire: 9 September – 10 September
  • Edgehill 375th Anniversary, Warwickshire: Sat 23 Sep 2017 – Sun 24 Sep 2017

Charlton Park, Wiltshire
Saturday 27 May – Monday 29 May

Buy your tickets in advance!

A major event at a stunning location in the Wiltshire countryside! The Sealed knot will bring to you the excitement of a battle with cannons roaring, cavalry charging, muskets volleying alongside a large living history camp which will be of interest to all ages. Have a word with the 17th Century suppliers of equipment and arms, see the work of the lace makers of the period alongside many more disciplines. Something for everyone, young and the young of heart.

ENTRANCE £15 PER CAR // £10 CAR SINGLE OCCUPANT // DISCOUNT WITH SCHOOL VOUCHER £10 PER CAR

Newark, Nottinghamshire
Saturday 22 July – Sunday 23 July

This July, the Sealed Knot will be returning to Newark to stage a battle reenactment on the sconce, one of the best-preserved English Civil War defences in the country.

On Saturday 22 July and Sunday 23 July, we will be helping stage spectacular English Civil War battles and providing an insight into how people lived and died at Newark in the 1640s.

Home to the National Civil War Museum, Newark is the ideal place to discover more about this important period in British history. From thunderous battles featuring cannons, muskets, pike, and cavalry, to the encampment showing you the life and times of the English Civil War, this is something not to be missed.

Children can take part in specially-organised pike drills on the camp, where there will be an assortment of trades and crafts of the period.

Tattershall Castle, Lincolnshire
Saturday 5 August – Sunday 6 August

Once again the Royalist forces of the Duke of Newcastle lay siege to the Parliamentarian garrison in the stunning castle, now run by the National Trust. Come and see the skirmish and wander through the living history village. Discover more >>

Scampston Hall, North Yorkshire
Saturday 26 August – Monday 28 August

Sealed Knot members from around the country will flock to North Yorkshire for the largest Civil War event in the UK!

A spectacular battle featuring hundreds of reenactors will crown a huge Bank Holiday weekend event – cannon, muskets, and drums will sound across the parkland surrounding this magnificent house.

This is the perfect chance to see the Sealed Knot at its best. Just 40 minutes from York and half an hour from Scarborough, this great location is an ideal Bank Holiday treat for the whole family!

Lancaster Castle
Saturday 9 September – Sunday 10 September

To arms! Step back to a turbulent time in Lancaster’s history as the English Civil War returns – from the town’s brave defenders to the castle’s stout walls keeping plundering Royalists at bay! The Earl of Manchester’s Regiment of Foote will be garrisoning the castle and giving the family the chance to experience what life was like in 1643 as King Charles and Parliament fought for control of the country. Witness live weapons demonstrations, talk to the soldiers, and see how people lived in the 17th Century in a superb educational day out for young and old alike. In this war without an enemy – which side will YOU choose?

LANCASTER-POSTER.jpg

Edgehill 375th Anniversary, Warwickshire
Saturday 23 September – Sunday 24 September

The Sealed Knot end their reenactment season with a special event marking 375 years since the Battle of Edgehill, the first major engagement of the English Civil Wars.

Both sides hoped that the battle next to the sleepy village of Kineton would decisively end the squabbles between King Charles and his Parliament, yet the mixed outcome merely heralded almost a decade of warfare across the British Isles.

Come and mark the occasion with us as we take part in a huge battle reenactment at this historical location!

Traitor at the Gate: who was Sir John Hotham, the man who closed the gates of Hull?

Standard

4.a.jpgOn 23 April 1642, a herald appeared at the gates in the fortifications of Hull that led to the road to nearby Beverley.

He called on the governor, Sir John Hotham, to open the gates and admit the King, Charles Stuart, who was nearby with 300 troops.

Hull was a strategic port and site of an arsenal left after the Bishops’ Wars against the Scottish Covenanters in 1638 and 1640. Already limbering up for armed conflict against Parliament, Charles wanted access to the weapons stored with its walls. Sir John’s job was to make sure he never got them.

So he refused.

Yet in just a few short months, the same Sir John would be negotiating with the King’s allies to surrender the town to the Royalists.

This Sunday, reenactors from the Sealed Knot and the Earl of Manchester’s Regiment of Foote will reenact this moment with members of Hull Playgoers Society, next to the actual remains of the Beverley Gate.

But who was Sir John Hotham?

With five marriages and military service on the Continent under his belt, Hotham was MP for Beverley. Dismissed from the governorship of Hull because of his objection to the Bishops’ Wars, which he thought would damage the fortunes of the northern counties, he was nonetheless elected MP for Beverley in the Long Parliament of 1640 and actively opposed the King. In January 1642, Parliament re-appointed him governor of Hull and told to head there forthwith.

Specifically instructed not to deliver up the town or its arsenal without Parliament’s authority, when the King appeared before the walls on 23 April 1642, Hotham barred the town gates and denied him entry. The King declared Hotham a traitor, but Parliament praised his actions. In July, the King returned with a small army and the first siege of Hull became the earliest military action of the English Civil War.

Wenceslas_Hollar_-_Hull.jpgHull’s strategic importance increased during 1643 when the military success of the Royalist general, the Marquis of Newcastle, against the Yorkshire forces of Sir Ferdinando and his son Thomas Fairfax, as well as the defection of Sir Hugh Cholmley at Scarborough, left the city as the only Parliamentarian stronghold in the county.

Rather than attack the city’s impressive walls, the Royalists instead turned their efforts to trying to convince Sir John to change sides. Hotham had grown disenchanted with the Parliamentarian cause and its leadership and had already entered into secret negotiations with Newcastle to surrender the town.

But the indiscreet behaviour of his eldest son, Captain John Hotham, aroused the suspicion of Parliamentarian commanders. Captain Hotham had originally secured Hull against the Royalists with the support of the radical MP Peregrine Pelham and the Yorkshire Trained Bands, the local militia force. But military blunders, the poor behaviour of his troops, and his resentment at Thomas Fairfax’s authority led to the secret negotiations.

At a rendezvous of Parliamentarian troops at Nottingham in June 1643, Colonels Cromwell and Hutchinson reported their suspicions to their superiors and and the arrest of Captain Hotham was ordered. He escaped from Nottingham and fled to Lincoln, but was arrested again when he went to confer with his father at Hull.

Sir John himself made a desperate attempt to escape but was finally arrested at Beverley.

So suspicious and angry had people become with Hotham’s behaviour that one detractor at the time marvelled that after his failed defection he “found nott soe much as one man to lift a hand on his behalf”. His arrest was not handled with kid gloves:

one musketeer battered Sir John, felling him from his horse and striking his face with a musket butt, inflicting a grievous wound from which Hotham suffered until his execution.

Both Hothams were imprisoned in the Tower of London but worse was to come – when Newcastle’s correspondence was captured after the battle of Marston Moor, the full extent of their plotting was revealed.

The popular Parliamentarian general Sir William Waller presided over the court-martial of the Hothams in December 1644. Sir John was found guilty of treason – thus earning the dubious distinction of being declared a traitor by both King and Parliament – and despite trying to lay all blame on his father, Captain Hotham too was condemned.

Hotham was beheaded on Tower Hill on 2 January 1645, the day after the execution of his son.

Sir John Hotham was characterised by both sides as a weak man and a turncoat who, despite his steadfast handling of the incident at the Beverley Gate in 1642, showed his true colours by prevaricating, possibly to buy himself time to see which side would be victorious. His son was a hot-headed and stubborn man whose actions undoubtedly helped lead him and his father to the scaffold.

As described in Andrew Hopper’s Turncoats and Renegadoes: Changing Sides during the English Civil Wars, there was – at least – one upside to Hotham’s wavering – it kept the King’s forces outside the gates of Hull:

Whether it was due to Sir John’s second thoughts or his deliberate sabotaging of their efforts, the royalists’ failure to secure Hull’s arms magazine led to the king’s army being poorly equipped at Edgehill – itself a decisive factor in their failure to inflict a crushing defeat on the Earl of Essex.

He may have been a traitor but Sir John Hotham, probably without realising, did the Parliamentary cause one big favour.